back arrowSouthern Mysteries Podcast

Episode 20: The Mystery of Old Mike


Episode description

In the summer of 1911 an unidentified man died in the railroad town of Prescott, Arkansas.  With no ID and no way to find his family, the town undertaker put the man’s body on public display for over 60 years. Who was this man? And why did it take 60 years to bury him? Find full show notes for this episode at

SUPPORT THE SHOW Buy merchandise in the Southern Mysteries Store

SPONSOR This episode of Southern Mysteries is brought to you by – get one free extra month of BarkBox at when you use code PBFEM

CONNECT  | Website | Twitter  | Facebook  | Discussion Group

MUSIC Theme Song “Dark & Troubled” by Panthernburn. Special thanks to Phillip St Ours for permission for use ***Additional Music: Nicolai Heidlas “Letting Go”; Nicolai Heidlas “Beyond”; Kevin MacLeod “Wounded”, “Mesmerize”, and “Cryptic Sorrow”; Whitesand “Passage” Licensed under Creative Commons Attribution

episodes iconMore Episodes

Episode 53 Grady Stiles The Life and Death of Lobster Boy

September 16th, 2019


Grady Stiles was a freak show performer, known as Lobster Boy, who was found murdered in his Gibstonton, Florida home in November of 1992. A detective wondered why none of his family seemed shocked or disappointed that …

Episode 52 The Murder of William Wise

September 2nd, 2019


In 1734, Alice Riley became the first person to be executed in the colony of Georgia. The servant was tried and convicted, alongside fellow servant, …

Episode 51 Murder At The Battery Park Hotel

August 19th, 2019


The murder of Helen Clevenger is one of Asheville, North Carolina’s most infamous crimes. In July of 1936, the 18 year old college student was …

Episode 50 The Star That Fell On Ann Hodges

July 22nd, 2019


In November 1954, Ann Hodges was resting in her Oak Grove, Alabama home when a meteorite crashed through her roof and hit her. She became the only known human being to survive a meteorite strike. Ann was thrown into a …

Episode 49 Russell Jones

July 8th, 2019


Rutherford County, Tennessee is known for its rich civil war history and stories. But deep within the county, in Murfreesboro, lies the story of the disappearance of Russell Jones. When his body was discovered in town, …

Episode 48 Lillian Knox The Lady Bountiful

June 24th, 2019


In 1922, Lillian Knox ran one of the largest lumber companies in the state of Texas. She was known for her business savvy, her take charge attitude and her acts of kindness to the timber families who worked hard to make …

Episode 47 Clotilda and Africa Town

June 10th, 2019


The last ship to bring slaves to America arrived in Alabama’s Mobile Bay in 1860, carrying in its hull more than 100 Africans who had been kidnapped …

Episode 46 The Boy Under The Billboard

May 27th, 2019


In September of 1998, the unidentified body of a 10 year old boy was found under a billboard, near a North Carolina highway. A determined …

Episode 45 Mary Elizabeth Tyler

May 13th, 2019


Meet Mary Elizabeth Tyler. Referred to as "the heartbeat of the Klan" during a Congressional investigation of the group's rise in the 1920s, Tyler used her skills as a publicist to rebrand the KKK and launch the Women's …

Episode 44 Clementine Hunter and the FBI Folk Art Forgery File

April 29th, 2019


One of the most detailed records of life along Louisiana's Cane River was told through paintings of folk artist, Clementine Hunter. In 2008, the FBI …

Episode 43 The Sleeping Preacher X+Y=Z

April 15th, 2019


In the late 19th century, Constantine Sanders was known as Alabama's Sleeping Preacher. Often writing down premonitions and visions from a "trance …

Episode 42 Mystery of Missing Heiress Jacqueline Levitz

April 1st, 2019


In October 1995, an heiress who had tired of high society life in Palm Beach, relocated to Vicksburg, Mississippi. She loved the slower pace of life along the Mississippi River. But within weeks of the move, 62 year …

Episode 41 Trapper Nelson Wild Man of Loxahatchee

March 18th, 2019


Vince "Trapper" Nelson turned his passion for panther trapping and gator wrestling into a Jungle Zoo along Florida's Loxahatchee River in the late 1930s. In 1968, he was found dead on the land that was about to make him …

Episode 40 The Ballad of Frankie Silver

March 4th, 2019


In 1833 Frankie Silver was hanged in Morganton, North Carolina for the murder of her husband Charlie. The story has lived on through the song "The …

Episode 39 Bessie Coleman

February 18th, 2019


Before Amelia Earhart broke barriers in the world of aviation, there was a Black Cherokee woman from Texas who used her love of aviation to break down racial barriers. But she was forced to leave the country she loved …

Episode 38 The Lost Treasure of the Beale Ciphers

February 4th, 2019


For 200 years, treasure hunters have traveled to Virginia to hunt for a buried treasure of gold, silver and jewels. Thomas Beale left behind 3 …

Episode 37 Connie Franklin Ghost of the Ozarks

January 21st, 2019


In 1929, five men in Stone County, Arkansas were charged in the murder of Connie Franklin. There would be many twists and the turns in the case. But …

Episode 36 Missing Bobby Dunbar

January 7th, 2019


In the summer of 1912, a four year old boy went missing while his family was camping near a Louisiana resort area. The day Bobby Dunbar disappeared …

Episode 35 Harry Tyson Moore

December 17th, 2018


His name may not be familiar to you but Harry T. Moore was the first martyr of the American Civil Rights Movement. He and his wife were murdered in their Florida home on Christmas Day 1951. Who killed the Moores? And …

Episode 34 Computer Con Murder

December 3rd, 2018


In the fall of 1992, Heather Uffelman and Jeremy Rolfs were seniors at Middle Tennessee State University. They loved each other and dreamed of a …

Episode 33 The Giggling Granny Nannie Doss

November 19th, 2018


From the 1920s until 1954, Nannie Doss was viewed as a sweet woman, a grandmother who was as sweet as pie. But in 1954, this Giggling Granny as she became known, confessed to close to a dozen murders

Connect on Facebook

Episode 32 Robert Smalls

November 5th, 2018


In 1862, an enslaved crew member of a Confederate steamship, stole the ship and sailed it past Confederate forces to deliver it to the Union. This …

Episode 31 Black Wedding

October 28th, 2018


In 1930, Elena Hoyos met Carl Von Cosel in Key West, Florida. Von Cosel became obsessed with her. This has been called a love story but it’s truly …

Episode 30 Greenbrier Ghost Dead Women Do Tell Tales

October 22nd, 2018


Zona Heaster Shue's life was cut short when she was murdered in 1897. She’s known in West Virginia lore as the Greenbrier Ghost because her ghost …

Episode 29: Wilmington Coup D'Etat

October 8th, 2018


In November 1898, the only successful coup d'etat in American history unfolded in North Carolina when the local government was overthrown by a group …

Episode 28: The Vengeful Abduction of Annie Laurie Hearin

September 24th, 2018


At 9:50pm on July 26,1988, the Jackson Mississippi Police Department received a call from 71 year old Robert Hearin reporting his 72 year old wife, …

Episode 27: Mammoth Cave Explorations, Experiments and Enemies

September 10th, 2018


Mammoth Cave is the longest cave system in the world. It was also ground zero for a desperate medical experiment and the Kentucky Cave Wars that …

Episode 26: Edgar Watson The Desperado of Chatham Bend

August 27th, 2018


The Florida Everglades are full of fascinating wildlife, eerie beauty and countless natural wonders. But within this dense wilderness, is the story …

Episode 25: The Living Funeral of Felix Bush

July 30th, 2018


In June of 1938, a Tennessee hermit threw himself a funeral party. The "living" funeral made Felix Bush famous. But why had Felix lived as a hermit for decades? And why did he decide to throw himself a funeral and …

Episode 24: Gribble House Murders of Savannah

July 16th, 2018


In December of 1909, three women were murdered in a violent axe attack in a boarding house in Savannah, Georgia known as the Gribble House. The …

Episode 23: Cahill Mansion

July 2nd, 2018


For decades families moved in and out of Cahill Mansion near Gulfport, Mississippi with stories of restless spirits inside including a pyromaniac …

Episode 22: Missing Sodder Family Children

June 18th, 2018


What happened to the Sodder children? Five siblings disappeared from their West Virginia home on Christmas Eve night in 1945. What was their fate? Were they kidnapped, murdered or did they meet another tragic fate? Find …

Episode 21 Love and Hatred in Birmingham - Murder of Father Coyle

June 4th, 2018


In 1921, a Methodist minister in Birmingham, Alabama, shot and killed a Catholic priest in broad daylight in front of witnesses. The resulting murder …

Episode 19 Frenchy McCormick and Tascosa, Texas

May 7th, 2018


Frenchy McCormick lived by herself in the Texas ghost town of Tascosa for almost 30 years. She refused to leave because of a promise she made to …

Episode 18 Hermit of Fort Fisher - Robert Harrill

April 23rd, 2018


 From 1955 - 1972, Robert Harrill was known as The Hermit of Fort Fisher Island, North Carolina. He spent his life inviting in strangers and teaching …

Episode 17: Three Sisters in Black

April 9th, 2018


Meet sisters Caroline Martin, Virginia Wardlaw and Mary Snead. They left a trail of devastation and death in Kentucky, Tennessee, Virginia, and on to …

Episode 16: Longwood Plantation Natchez - Nutt's Folly

March 26th, 2018


Longwood Plantation in Natchez, Mississippi epitomizes the rise and fall of the antebellum south. The history of the home may explain why spirits of …

Episode 15: William Johnson Barber of Natchez

March 19th, 2018


On June 16, 1851 William Johnson was murdered. 75 years later, his diary was discovered and became one of the most important firsthand accounts of life in the antebellum South. What was his story? And how did the man …

Episode 14: Natchez City Cemetery

March 12th, 2018


Natchez City Cemetery is one of the most beautiful cemeteries in the South. Behind each monument, beneath each grave site, is a story of a life …

Episode 13: Goat Castle Murder of Natchez

March 5th, 2018


Historian, Karen L. Cox, is the author of  Goat Castle: A True Story of Murder, Race, and the Gothic South. Karen discusses the 1932 murder of Jenny Merrill, the eccentric couple who were arrested and charged with …

Episode 12: Coral Castle - The Taj Mahal of the South

February 26th, 2018


Imagine a 5 foot tall, 100 pound heartbroken man excavating, shaping and hoisting massive coral blocks into a structure all by himself. Literally building walls to try to deal with a broken heart. This is the story of …

Episode 10: Loreta Velazquez

January 21st, 2018



Loreta Velazquez challenged gender, social and ethnic boundaries during the Civil War. The story of her life has been shrouded in mystery and debated for generations. Who was Loreta? What made her story so dangerous …

Episode 9: Lands End Road

January 1st, 2018


Three legendary haunts along the eight mile stretch of Lands End Road on St Helena Island, South Carolina, have led to this road being named one of …

Episode 6: Death Keeps A Tryst - Thomas Hotard and Audrey Moate

December 4th, 2017


On November 24, 1956, Thomas Hotard was discovered murdered near Lake Ponchatrain in Louisiana. His lover, Audrey Moate went missing the same day. …

Episode 4: Georgia Tann's Children

November 12th, 2017


From the 1920s until 1950, Georgia Tann used a network of powerful accomplices to take advantage of the poor and helpless in and around Memphis, …

Episode 3: The Legend of the Pope Lick Monster

October 31st, 2017


The Pope Lick Monster is an urban legend that has led countless seekers to a dangerous trestle bridge in Louisville, Kentucky. Keith Age, of SyFy …

Episode 2: It's Raining Strange Eels

October 30th, 2017


In 1892 The New York Sun published a story about strange eels raining on small town Coalburg, Alabama. Did it really happen or was this a tall tale …

Episode 1: The Phantom Barber

October 29th, 2017


Sandra Moncrief, author of “The Phantom Barber” discusses her theories of the man who terrorized residents of Pascagoula, Mississippi in the summer …

Loading ...

Download the RadioPublic app for
 FREE and never miss an episode.

Get it on Google PlayDownload on the App Store